February 1971. Quadrafonic Sound, Nashville. Neil Young is cutting the songs that will become Harvest — Kenny Buttrey on drums, Tim Drummond on bass, Jack Nitzsche on piano — and a pedal steel player nobody in Young's California circle has met before. A Nashville session ace named Ben Keith. What Ben Keith plays on those sessions, and on the four decades of Young records that follow, is one of the great uncelebrated performances in American music.
He is barely there. He is everywhere. The steel guitar on "Old Man" does not play a melody so much as bend a curtain of longing across it — rising into moments, settling out of them. Young came to describe Keith as an extension of his own guitar. That is the correct description. It is one instrument played by two people.
Here is the secret of the pedal steel that most producers never quite say aloud. The steel cannot play a note the way a piano plays a note. It is always in transit. Its home position is a bend. Every attack blurs into a swell, every release trails, every chord is a slow decision the ear watches unfold. It cannot punctuate. It can only trail. Which means the steel does not compete with a vocal. It companions it. It says the thing the singer left out.
That is why country and Americana records so often feel emotional even when the arrangement is doing almost nothing. The steel is running underneath, smearing the transitions, filling the spaces between the words with a kind of held breath. Take it away from Merle Haggard's "Silver Wings," from George Jones's "He Stopped Loving Her Today," from Ray Price's "Nightlife," and the songs stand there uncovered. They can still sing. But they have lost their weather.
The great pedal steel players understand something the rest of us learn slowly. The point is not to play. The point is to know when the singer needs the room to be a little warmer and to make it warmer without anyone noticing. Ben Keith almost never plays a solo on a Neil Young record. He plays a climate. Lloyd Green does the same behind five decades of Nashville sessions. Buddy Emmons, who could technically play anything, spent a career choosing not to. Bucky Baxter, on Bob Dylan's Time Out of Mind, is doing so little that engineers were reportedly told not to turn him up. Turning him up killed the illusion.
The principle generalizes past pedal steel. The instrument that carries a record is not the loudest one in the arrangement. It is the one whose absence you would feel first. Everyone can hear a lead guitar solo leave. Very few people can hear a steel leave. But they will feel the room get cold.
Ben Keith died in 2010 on Neil Young's ranch in California, where he had lived and worked in his later years. There is a warmth on those Harvest records that came from a specific set of hands. There are some places you cannot fill.
One essay like this, every week
The craft, history, and business of music — written for people who make it. Get the next one by email.